When someone is harmed by another party’s act — deceived in a transaction, defamed, or deprived of an asset — civil law provides a route to claim damages. The most commonly used basis is the unlawful act, governed by Article 1365 of the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPerdata), which provides that any unlawful act causing loss obliges the wrongdoer to compensate for that loss.
Four elements that must be proven
An unlawful-act claim is not granted automatically. The claimant must prove all four of the following elements:
- An unlawful act — the act violates the law, another person’s rights, or accepted standards of decency and propriety.
- Fault — the wrongdoer acted intentionally or negligently.
- Loss — the claimant suffered real loss, whether material or immaterial.
- Causation — the loss arose because of that act.
If any element is not proven, the claim may be rejected. That is why preparing evidence from the outset is decisive.
Unlawful act or breach of contract?
The two are often confused. Breach of contract arises from an agreement: one party fails to perform what was promised. An unlawful act arises from the law itself and needs no agreement. In practice, one event can involve both — for example, a business partner who fails to pay and also falsifies documents. Choosing the right legal basis affects strategy, evidence, and the relief requested.
What can be claimed?
Generally, a claimant may seek material damages — such as costs already incurred and lost profits — as well as immaterial damages for suffering or reputational harm. In certain circumstances, the claimant may also ask the court to order restoration to the original condition or to prohibit the act from continuing.
First steps before filing suit
Before filing, gather evidence: contracts, receipts, messages, photographs, and witness statements. Send a written demand (somasi) so the other party has a chance to settle amicably. Many disputes end at this stage. If not, mediation or a court claim is the next step — noting that civil cases generally must go through mediation first.
This article is general information and not legal advice. How any matter is handled depends on its facts and evidence; consult an advocate or legal counsel before taking legal steps.
